Menu
BrowseMembersCategoriesAbout
Birth
Birth

Birth

October 29, 2004· 1h 40m
Directed by
Cinemagraphs Score6.1

It took Anna 10 years to recover from the death of her husband, Sean, but now she's on the verge of marrying her boyfriend, Joseph, and finally moving on. However, on the night of her engagement party, a young boy named Sean turns up, saying he is her dead husband reincarnated. At first she ignores the child, but his knowledge of her former husband's life is uncanny, leading her to believe that he might be telling the truth.

Critics Sentiment

Critics6.1
No audience data yet —
1 — Hated it5 — Neutral10 — Masterpiece
Critics
|
8+ Great
6-8 Good
<6 Poor
15 reviews·Last updated 28d ago
Peak Moment

Anna sits in contemplation during the extended theater sequence

8.5at 60m
Lowest Moment

Anna marries Joseph on the beach and wades into the ocean in anguish

4.2at 1h 36m
Biggest Swing

The film peaks with Kidman's acclaimed theater closeup then steadily declines through the controversial kiss scene to the widely criticized ending

Birth opens with strong cinematic craft and an intriguing premise that captivates viewers, building to a transcendent moment with Kidman's extended closeup. However, the film becomes increasingly uncomfortable and divisive through its controversial middle section before ending on a widely criticized note that leaves too many questions unanswered. Critics appreciated the filmmaking artistry and performances while finding the narrative ultimately unsatisfying.

15 reviews analyzed|Sources: Imdb, Tmdb
Sign in or create a free account to contribute your review

Write a Review

15.510

Rate each story beat:

Sean lectures about disbelief in reincarnation before his fatal jog
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Anna accepts Joseph's marriage proposal ten years after Sean's death
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
The ten year old boy sneaks into Anna's apartment claiming to be Sean
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Joseph rushes downstairs to confront the boy with Sean's father
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Anna sits in contemplation during the extended theater sequence⬆ Peak moment
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Joseph physically attacks the boy out of jealousy and concern
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Clara confronts Sean with the love letters and her affair with the dead Sean
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Anna marries Joseph on the beach and wades into the ocean in anguish⬇ Lowest moment
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it

Similar films