Menu
BrowseMembersCategoriesAbout
In the Hand of Dante
In the Hand of Dante

In the Hand of Dante

June 12, 2026· 2h 33m
Directed by
Cinemagraphs Score5.4

A Vatican priest discovers Dante's original Divine Comedy manuscript. When asked to authenticate it, writer Nick Tosches steals it, while a parallel story follows Dante's quest to create his masterpiece.

Critics Sentiment

Critics5.4
No audience data yet —
1 — Hated it5 — Neutral10 — Masterpiece
Critics
|
8+ Great
6-8 Good
<6 Poor
18 reviews·Last updated 9d ago
Peak Moment

Al Pacino appears as Uncle Carmine in a scene reviewers called the film's best four minutes

7.2at 38m
Lowest Moment

The film's conclusion feels forced and fails to deliver emotional or thematic payoff

3.5at 2h 20m
Biggest Swing

The film drops from its energetic early peak around the Pacino cameo (7.2) into the grinding incoherence of the final third (3.5), a swing of 3.7 points that mirrors reviewers' near-universal complaint that the film's first two-thirds are squandered by a pretentious and sentimental collapse.

In the Hand of Dante opens with genuine energy and visual ambition, earning goodwill through Butler's crime-world charisma, Isaac's committed dual performance, and standout cameos from Pacino and Scorsese. The middle section begins to buckle under the weight of its own literary pretensions, with the timeline crosscutting losing rhythm and Gadot's performance drawing sharp criticism. The final third collapses almost entirely, with reviewers broadly agreeing that the film trades its scabrous black comedy for solemn romantic fantasy, leaving a talented cast and a fascinating source novel feeling thoroughly wasted.

18 reviews analyzed|Sources: Imdb, Guardian
Sign in or create a free account to contribute your review

Write a Review

15.510

Rate each story beat:

Schnabel opens the film across 14th-century Florence and modern New York
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Gerard Butler's tough-guy character is introduced in the modern crime world
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Al Pacino appears as Uncle Carmine in a scene reviewers called the film's best four minutes⬆ Peak moment
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
The film's monochrome photography reaches its most visually striking passages
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
The film's back-and-forth between medieval and modern timelines begins to lose narrative clarity
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Literary and historical references accumulate without coalescing into emotional or narrative meaning
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
The film's conclusion feels forced and fails to deliver emotional or thematic payoff⬇ Lowest moment
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
The film closes leaving reviewers with a sense of squandered cast and concept
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it