

Ice Cream Man
An idyllic summer town descends into madness when an ice cream man serves kids sweet delights with horrifying results.
Critics Sentiment
The priest explains Jonathan Smiley's unjust conviction and the necromancer's deal in the church basement
Jared and Lizzie stab the grave bodies and realize too late they have killed their own parents
Sentiment drops sharply from the relative high of the Jonathan Smiley backstory reveal at the church basement (5.0) into the grim, widely-derided cemetery sequence and parent-killing twist (2.0), a swing of 3.0 points across roughly 25 minutes.
Ice Cream Man opens to immediate skepticism, with reviewers citing wooden acting, artless filmmaking, and a paper-thin premise from the first frame. A brief uptick around the midpoint backstory reveal is the film's lone relative bright spot, before the nonsensical twist ending and AI-assisted sequences drive sentiment to its lowest ebb. The overwhelming critical and audience consensus is that the film is a disappointing, often offensive misfire that squanders its gory premise through lazy execution and a complete absence of tension or consequence.
Full cast
Showing 20 of 43
Ari Millen
The Ice Cream Man

Charlie Zeltzer
Jared

Shiloh O’Reilly
Tommy
Kiori Mirza Waldman
Mia

Sarah Abbott
Lizzie

Benjamin Byron Davis
The Priest

Karen Cliche
Alison

Dylan Hawco
Chris

Eli Roth
Marty
Charlie Storey
Piper
Andriah Bryan
Mrs. Valentine

Darrin Baker
Principal Maloney

Rodrigo Fernandez-Stoll
Mr. Hamlin

Alex Armbruster
Jogger

Lochlan Ray Miller
Boy with Pennies #1

Lorenzo Antonucci
Terry

Carina Battrick
Marcella
Tyler Ronald
SSE Kid Force Fed Ice Cream

Amanda Barker
Heather Henderson

Luke Dietz
Elliot
Crew
Write a Review
Rate each story beat:
0 of 8 rated
Beats you skip are left out of your arc.