Tragedy Girls
McKayla and Sadie, two death-obsessed teenage girls, use their online show about real-life tragedies to send their small Midwestern town into a frenzy and cement their legacy as modern horror legends.
Critics Sentiment
McKayla and Sadie decapitate Big Al with bench press
Jordan steals evidence and breaks away from the girls
The film drops significantly during Jordan's betrayal subplot but recovers as it builds toward the prom climax.
Tragedy Girls starts strong with its modern social media premise and inventive kills, particularly the praised gym scene. However, it struggles with tonal consistency and moral clarity, especially in its divisive ending that left critics uncertain about the film's intentions.
Full cast
Showing 20 of 26
Brianna Hildebrand
Sadie Cunningham
Alexandra Shipp
McKayla Hooper
Jack Quaid
Jordan Welch
Kevin Durand
Lowell Lehmann
Timothy V. Murphy
Sheriff Blane Welch
Katie Stottlemire
Bookish Student
Nicky Whelan
Mrs. Kent
Elise Neal
Mrs. Hooper
Craig Robinson
Big Al
Andy Bethea
Mr. Hooper
Keith Hudson
Chuck Cunningham
Savannah Jayde
Syl Stanton
Austin Abrams
Craig Thompson
William Tokarsky
Mr. Gordon
Marycarmen Lopez
Trish
Loren Lester
Principal Reid
Rosalind Chao
Mayor Campbell
Kerry Rhodes
Drew
Jenna Day
Fangirl #1
Sophia Mitchell
Fangirl #2
Crew
Write a Review
Rate each story beat:
