Menu
BrowseMembersCategoriesAbout
I Can Only Imagine 2
I Can Only Imagine 2

I Can Only Imagine 2

February 19, 2026· 1h 50m
Cinemagraphs Score7.8

Following the breakout success of the song 'I Can Only Imagine', MercyMe's Bart Millard is living the dream—sold-out arenas, a devoted fanbase, and a thriving career. But behind the spotlight, Bart's past threatens the family he's built, especially the fragile bond with his son Sam. When hopeful newcomer Tim Timmons joins the band for their biggest tour yet, he unknowingly brings a renewed gratitude to Bart's life through their unlikely friendship. Bart soon discovers that Tim carries hardships—and secrets—of his own, forcing him to face his past and repair his relationships with Sam and his wife Shannon before fame costs him what matters most.

Critics Sentiment

Critics7.8
No audience data yet —
1 — Hated it5 — Neutral10 — Masterpiece
Critics
|
8+ Great
6-8 Good
<6 Poor
16 reviews·Last updated 6d ago
Peak Moment

Bart performs Even If at Red Rocks tribute

9.2at 1h 45m
Lowest Moment

Bart wins Song of the Year at GMA Dove Awards

6.5at 5m
Biggest Swing

The film rises dramatically from its formulaic opening to the transcendent Red Rocks finale, gaining nearly 3 points as it finds its emotional core.

I Can Only Imagine 2 starts cautiously with familiar faith-film tropes but builds steadily through genuine character relationships and Tim Timmons' compelling arc. The film peaks with its climactic musical performance, delivering the emotional payoff that transforms a safe sequel into something genuinely moving. Critics consistently praised Milo Ventimiglia's performance and the film's exploration of gratitude and mortality.

16 reviews analyzed|Sources: Imdb
Sign in or create a free account to contribute your review

Write a Review

15.510

Rate each story beat:

Bart wins Song of the Year at GMA Dove Awards⬇ Lowest moment
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Sam suffers seizure and receives Type 1 diabetes diagnosis
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Tim Timmons befriends Sam and encourages his musical performance
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Tim explains Horatio Spafford's tragic story behind the hymn
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Bart and Sam argue about removed tour participation
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Tim reveals cancer diagnosis and pregnancy to Bart
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Tim found unconscious and rushed to hospital emergency
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it
Bart performs Even If at Red Rocks tribute⬆ Peak moment
5.0
Hated itNeutralLoved it

Similar films